Saturday, April 10, 2004
A Computer for Rs 5,000

I wrote an article for The Economic Times supplement "India Rising" [it appeared a couple days ago]:

India Shining has been, among other things, about building India’s physical infrastructure. Yet, India’s digital infrastructure lags with an installed base of just 10 million computers. The computer is arguably one of the most important creations of the past quarter century. It has bridged divides, transformed industries, and been at the heart of the IT revolution that has been one of the key anchors of India’s growth as an outsourcing centre. But much of India still remains untouched by the computer revolution. What we need is an India Computing drive to ensure that there is a connected computer accessible to every family and every employee in India.

The computer can be the vehicle for opening up new windows and opportunities. For the first generation of users over the past quarter century, it has done just that. Neither the TV nor the telephone (or the cellphone) can match the computer’s interactive platform which enables its users to connect to each other, information and applications. The PC has engineered the technology and productivity revolution in the developed markets in the past two decades, flanked by the Internet and cheap connectivity. So, the question is: how can the PC now be taken across the digital divide to the next generation of users?

One of the key factors that has inhibited the growth of computers in India is their cost. Even with the recent reduction in duty, the computer still costs Rs 18-20,000. Add the price of legal software and the investment can touch Rs 45-50,000. So far, the options in India have been non-consumption of hardware and piracy of software. Both are not going to take us far.

We can learn from the mobile phone revolution that has permeated across India in the past two years. India is now adding 2.5 million new cellphone users each month, on a base of 30 million. In comparison, new computers are being added at just over a tenth at 300,000 each month.

Both TVs and cellphones took off in India when the price points dropped to the Rs 5,000 level. Something similar needs to take place with computers. What India needs to build a mass market for computers is an affordable computing solution – one which combines the business model of a cellphone combined with functionality, footprint and versatility of a computer. How do we make it happen? Think Disruptive Innovation.

Wrote Stuart Hart and Clayton Christensen in Sloan Management Review: “Disruptive Innovations compete against non-consumption – that is, they offer a product or service to people who would otherwise be left out entirely or poorly served by existing products and who are therefore quite happy to have a simpler, more modest version of what is available in the high-end markets.”

To take computing to the masses in India, we need to rethink the design of the personal computer. In the late 1970s and early 1980s when the PC was architected, networks did not exist. The PC was, in effect, a standalone device. This is no longer the case now. Local area networks and broadband networks offer high-speed, always-on connectivity. In addition, the continuous progress in semiconductors has ensured that processing power is available quite inexpensively. As a result, it is possible to think of a “thin client” with processing and storage taking place on a “thick server.” This disruptive innovation is the Rs 5,000 PC (5KPC).

The 5KPC is, in essence, a network computer. It “lights” up in the presence of a network. This is very similar to a cellphone or a television today. Both need networks to function. Without the cellular network, the cellphone is little more than a clock and good for a few games. Without the cable network, the television screen displays only static. In fact, think of some of the other devices we use – our regular landline telephone and radio. Both are network devices in the sense that without the connectivity they are useless.

The 5KPC never needs to be upgraded – all the processing happens on the server in the network. This is one of the reasons its administration is simplified. (We rarely need to call customer support for our telephone.) For the 5KPC, the network connectivity is what makes it come alive – the network provides the digital dial-tone.

This simplification also ensures that the 5KPC is a zero-maintenance device – the next set of users are not going to be half as savvy as the first generation in worrying about upgrades, device drivers and the like. Also, they are likely to be deployed in markets where customer support may not be easy to get. In addition, the 5KPC is rugged – because there are no moving parts, it can work in various conditions and requires a lot less power.

The idea of server-centric computing is not new in itself. Mainframe and minicomputers earlier used the same principle of centralised computing. What is innovative in the 5KPC is that we are applying it to the desktop without compromising the functionality or performance of the computer in any way.

Combined with open-source software built on Linux, the 5KPC can be at the vanguard of a digital revolution in India. It opens up new markets which hitherto have remained invisible because of the high cost of computing. India has an opportunity to absorb 100 million computers in the next 5 years:

  • 1 million schools need 10 computers each for enabling primary and secondary education
  • 100,000 colleges need 100 computers each to ensure digitally literate graduates
  • 3 million small- and medium-sized enterprises need to computer-enable their 30 million information-driven workforce
  • 40 million urban and semi-urban families need a computer
  • 5 million staff in government need computers to build the foundation for electronic and efficient governance
  • 5,000 hubs in rural India need 1,000 computers each to provide newer opportunities beyond agriculture and provide a foundation for transforming Bharat

    The market for the 5KPC extends beyond India. It provides the core for the computing platform for the next 500 million users in the world, primarily from the emerging markets. By itself, it will not bridge the digital divide, increase growth rates or eliminate poverty. But for the world’s poorest countries, the 5KPC can be an equaliser. It can open up new vistas and fire up people’s imaginations. After that, it is to the individuals and the enterprises to convert these openings into dramatically better futures. It is up to this generation of entrepreneurs to go and build out the 5KPC Ecosystem. India has the right mix to lead the way – hardware design and assembly skills, software development talent, a growing workforce to offer complementary services, and most importantly, a captive domestic market.

    Thin Client-Thick Server | PermaLink | Comments (3)

    I am a bit susceptical about the 5KPC eco-system. Though it offers a solution to the problem, but the key point for this eco-system to develop is the network infrastructure, which is not yet mature, widely available and administration free as compared to the cable, telephone, mobile or radio.

    Efforts like the Sun Ray failed to provide a low-cost thin client computing platform. I see two major problems - even if the cost problem is solved. First how usable can we make the linux based software, so that it poses a minimum learning curve to people unaware of the PC world.
    Secondly how effective can we make the whole thing plug & play. If in a primary school there's a need 10 thin clients, then either we need to put a thick server which enables these 10 clients in the same school (which implies administration) or secondly say a regional hub (which implies network infrastructure has to be high speed).

    Devices like radio, television, phones are more of passive devices. But PC being a highly interactive device, poses lot other constraints along with the cost factor.

    And we still are missing the right content on PCs in India. I have some of my uncles living in rural India. Though they understand perhaps computers are important for their kids but I haven't been able to give them a strong reason to make them learn and use a PC and Internet for themselves. We need to much better understand where and how the PC and Internet environment can give benefits to people in rural india. Some times I try to think if it's a complexity problem, my father who is a computer novice (tried to make him learn use internet) finds hard to use a PC for email but can very easily send an sms.

    China has started making a breakthrough in the growing number of PCs. May be some one can point out the real reason behind that?

    Posted by Sunil Goyal

    Besides the cost, I am yet to be convinced of a few other things.

    What is the content that majority of indians would like delivered via a PC? what is a farmer, a teacher, a student, looking for everyday as content and communication ? Can a low-cost PC deliver it?

    Anything that does not address these is a non-starter as far as majority of Indians are concerned. At present, the content that is accessible using a PC (assuming connectivity) is almost completely useless for an average Indian. Cellphones are very different in this sense. Everyone uses it - Farmer, teacher, student, truck drivers (in my hometown).

    Nevertheless, the usefulness and the things that computers enable can't be denied. They are necessary. But, in what guise should they penetrate the Indian society and for what reasons are the most important questions. As long as the common Indian remains unconvinced of it's uses, he will not buy it whatever the cost is. Be it Rs.5000 or Rs.500.

    The argument that low-cost PC's will enable a revolution does not excite me much if there isn't much content that a low-cost PC would deliver. It's a chicken-egg problem. But I think useful and accessible content should drive the cost of computing gadets (be it PC, Network computer, Simputer or anything) down rather than the other way around. It has happened in may other areas (TV, cellphones) and seems plausible with computing too.

    regards,
    Selva.

    Posted by Selva

    I am curious to know the source for the total installed base of computers in India. I would definitely like to read such a statistical study. If the author does know of one, please post a link to it.

    I also agree with Selva upon the fact that content is the most important factor in anyone adopting a computer. It works at all levels.

    My parents had no interest in learning how to use a computer until I showed them how they could manage their family business accounts, or keep in touch with me using the internet. Similarly, a farmer in rural India needs to see some content/application that he can use. Otherwise why would he take the time to get a computer? The job then comes down to people who are experts in the respective fields to build applications/provide content to benefit such users. Simply making machines that are 'affordable' might not be the end all.

    Posted by Prashant Mullick
  • Hospitals learn from Toyota

    An interesting article in WSJ about how hospitals are adopting techniques from Toyota's production techniques to cut costs and wait times:


    In the factories of Toyota Motor Corp., any worker who spots a serious problem can pull a cord and stop the assembly line...The Toyota system emphasizes the smoothest possible flow of work -- accomplished by, say, mapping out work processes and eliminating unnecessary steps, and using teamwork to identify and fix problems as soon as they crop up. Hospitals are using the tactics to reduce patient waiting times, slash wheelchair inventories, prepare operating rooms faster and move patients through a hospital stay or doctor visit quickly, seamlessly and error free.

    Some U.S. manufacturers are pushing the Toyota approach from factory floor to hospital ward, as part of their continuing effort to hold down rising employee health-care costs. Local industrial executives, who have been through wrenching Toyota-inspired changes in their own businesses, are promoting the techniques to their counterparts in hospitals.

    How Toyota's production techniques are applied to hospitals:

  • Flow: In a factory, the Toyota approach emphasizes the smooth flow of people, gear and finished goods. In hospitals, it emphasizes rapid flow of patients, staff.

  • Root-Cause Analysis: In a factory or hospital, errors are examined immediately, and countermeasures taken to avoid a repetition.

  • Value Stream Mapping: Workers diagram work processes, aiming to
    eliminate steps that aren't valuable to customers -- or patients.

  • Kaizen: This Japanese term for continuous improvement involves constant small steps to improve efficiency.
  • Sometimes Success Begins at Failure

    [via Veer] From a HBS Working Knowledge article by Henry Chesbrough: "Projects that appear to be duds may have unintended upsides—Viagra started life and failed as a drug for hypertension. Here are tips for turning negative test results into gold."


    The management of false negatives is much more complex. False negatives are not only often difficult to recognize, but there is also no single, sure-fire way to deal with them. Meanwhile, the downside to ignoring them is virtually impossible to predict. Nevertheless, history has shown it can be a costly mistake to miss a false negative, and there are indeed steps that companies can take to mitigate the likelihood of their development.

    So, what processes might cope with false negatives?

    - Review all canceled projects
    - Expose projects to outsiders
    - Seek external licenses
    - Spin technologies off
    - Seek external VC partners

    Entrepreneurship | PermaLink | Comments (1)

    Hi, nice work, if you have the necessary time, please vistit me, you'll find interesting stuff, articles about men health.

    Posted by penis enlargement
    Me
    Entrepreneur, Mumbai, India, Emergic, Netcore, Internet, IndiaWorld, Sify, IIT-Bombay, ColumbiaUniv ... More [Write to Me]

    - MyToday
    - Emergic Ecosystem
    - Netcore
    - Emergic MailServ: Enterprise Messaging
    - Emergic CleanMail: Anti-Virus, Anti-Spam
    - BlogStreet: Blog Profiles, RSS Ecosystem
    - Novatium: Network Computers
    - SEraja: The EventWeb
    - Rajshri Media: Broadband Portal
    - Newsweek on Novatium (Feb 2007)
    - Knowledge@Wharton Interview (Oct 2006)
    - TIME Asia (Mar 2000)

    Free SMS Updates
    Indian mobile users can sms START EMERGIC to 9845398453 to get free daily updates on new additions. [To unsubscribe, sms STOP EMERGIC to 9845398453.]
    My Writings
    Affordable Computing and ICT for Development
    India's Digital Infrastructure (May 2007)
    Envisioning Tomorrow's World (Mar 2007)
    Computing for the Next Billion (Jun 2006)
    City Wi-Fi Networks (Apr 2006)
    Microsoft Live (Nov 2005)
    Internet Tea Leaves (Sep 2005)
    Next-Generation Networks (Jul 2005)
    Disruptions (Jul 2005)
    The Mobile Phone Platform (Feb 2005)
    Microsoft, Bandwidth and Centralised Computing (Jan 2005)
    Computing for Broadband 101 (Jan 2005)
    Tomorrow's World (Nov 2004)
    CommPuting Grid (Nov 2004)
    Massputers, Redux (Oct 2004)
    The Network Computer (Oct 2004)
    Reinventing Computing (Aug 2004)
    Tech Trends (Jul 2004)
    Letter to Arun Shourie (Apr 2004)
    As India Develops (Mar 2004)
    My Mental Model (Dec 2003)
    The Next Billion (Sep 2003)
    Transforming Rural India 2 (Jul 2003)
    The Discovery of India (Jun 2003)
    Transforming Rural India (Mar 2003)
    The Rs 5,000 PC Ecosystem (Jan 2003)
    Disruptive Bridges (Nov 2002)
    India Post: Ideas for Tomorrow (Nov 2002)
    Technology's Next Markets (Oct 2002)
    Server-based Computing (Jul 2002)
    India's Next Decade (Apr 2002)
    The Digital Divide (Apr 2002)
    The Real Wireless Revolution (Mar 2002)
    Envisioning a New India (Jan 2002)
    Emerging Technologies, Emerging Markets (Jan 2002)
    The Indianised Linux Desktop (Nov 2001)
    Mass Market Internet (Nov 2000)

    Enterprise Software and SMEs
    The Coming Age of ASPs (May 2005)
    SMEs and Technology (Oct 2003)
    The Death and Rebirth of Email (Aug 2003)
    IT's Future (Aug 2003)
    Rethinking the Desktop (Sep 2002)
    Rethinking Enterprise Software (Jun 2002)
    Emerging Enterprises and Emergent Networks (Mar 2002)
    Web Services (Nov 2001)
    Alt.Software (Oct 2001)
    The Intelligent, Real-Time Enterprise (June 2001)
    Enterprise Software (Mar 2001)
    SME Tech Utility (Feb 2001)
    Software and SMEs (Jan 2001)
    The Intelligent Enterprise: Integrating CRM, SCM and EIP (Jan 2001)

    Information Management
    The Emerging Internet (May 2007)
    The Now-New-Near Web (Sep 2006)
    Mobile Internet (Aug 2006)
    Video on the Internet (Jun 2006)
    India Internet and Mobile (Feb 2006)
    Rethinking Newspapers (Jan 2006)
    Web 2.0 (Oct 2005)
    The Future of Search (Mar 2005)
    Web 2.0 Conference (Oct 2004)
    Thinking A New Food Portal (Sep 2004)
    Rethinking Search (Jan 2004)
    India.com 2.0 (Jan 2004)
    The Publish-Subscribe Web (Jun 2003)
    Constructing the Memex (May 2003)
    RSS, Blogs and Beyond (Feb 2003)
    Blogging (Feb 2002)
    Harnessing Information (Oct 2001)
    News Refinery (May 2001)

    Entrepreneurship
    When Bad Things Happen (Jan 2007)
    Ventures and Capital (Dec 2006)
    15 Years as an Entrepreneur (Nov 2006)
    Of Blue Oceans and Black Swans (May 2006)
    Let's Build a Business (Apr 2006)
    The Value of Vision (Mar 2006)
    Vision and Worries (Oct 2005)
    Bootstrapping a Business (Oct 2005)
    India Needs More Entrepreneurs (Aug 2005)
    Dotcom Nostalgia (Jun 2005)
    When Things Go Wrong (Apr 2005)
    My Life as an Entrepreneur (Nov 2004)
    An Entrepreneur's Growth Challenge (Sep 2004)
    Creating Options (Sep 2004)
    From Employee to Entrepreneur (Aug 2004)
    A Tale of Two Summers (Aug 2004)
    Crucible Experiences (May 2004)
    The Company (May 2004)
    An Entrepreneur's Attributes (Nov 2003)
    An Entrepreneur's Early Days (Sep 2003)
    Reflections on Ideas and Entrepreneurship (Jul 2003)
    Entrepreneur's Enigmas (Jan 2003)
    The Entrepreneur's Delights (Sep 2002)
    Life as an Entrepreneur (Oct 2001)
    Leadership Lessons from Lagaan (Aug 2001)
    Entrepreneurial Learnings (July 2001)
    Entrepreneurship (Mar 2001)
    The IndiaWorld Story (1997-8)

    Abhishek (my son)
    Photos
    Letter to a Two-Year-Old (Apr 2007)
    Father to Son (Apr 2006)
    Letter to a 2005 Baby (Jun 2005)
    The Making of Abhishek (Jul 2005)

    Moreover
    Facebook (May 2007)
    Doing Education Right (May 2007)
    Reflections from a Dubai Trip (Apr 2007)
    Creating India's New Cities (Apr 2007)
    India's Challenges (Mar 2007)
    3GSM 2007 (Feb 2007)
    Demo 2007 (Feb 2007)
    A Tale of Two Covers (Feb 2007)
    3GSM Mumbai (Feb 2007)
    2007 Tech Trends (Jan 2007)
    The Best of 2006 (Dec 2006)
    Best of Tech Talk 2006 (Dec 2006)
    Cyworld (Nov 2006)
    Two 2.0 Events (Nov 2006)
    Two-Sided Markets (Nov 2006)
    The Rise of YouTube (Oct 2006)
    Gandhigiri (Oct 2006)
    Education and Reservation (May 2006)
    Four Blog Years (May 2006)
    Fooled by Randomness (May 2006)
    Blue Ocean Strategy (May 2006)
    Revolution on the Roads (Apr 2006)
    The MySpace Story (Mar 2006)
    A Presentation at PC Forum (Mar 2006)
    Extreme Competition (Mar 2006)
    3GSM World Congress 2006 (Feb 2006)
    DEMO 2006 (Feb 2006)
    India Rising (Jan 2006)
    2006 Tech Trends (Jan 2006)
    The Best of Tech Talk 2005 (Dec 2005)
    The Best of 2005 (Dec 2005)
    Trains, Planes and Mobiles (Dec 2005)
    Peter Drucker: Management's Newton (Nov 2005)
    India Empowered (Oct 2005)
    Rajasthan Ruminations 2 (Sep 2005)
    Building a Better India (Sep 2005)
    South Korea's IT839 (Jul 2005)
    Shift-Ctrl (Jul 2005)
    Best of Future Tech (Feb 2005)
    Multi-Model Minds (Feb 2005)
    The Best of 2004 (Jan 2005)
    On Watching Swades (Jan 2005)
    The Best of Tech Talk 2004 (Dec 2004)
    India Trends (Dec 2004)
    An American Journey (Aug 2004)
    Black Swans (Aug 2004)
    A Train Journey (Jun 2004)
    An Agenda for the Next Government (May 2004)
    Two Blog Years (May 2004)
    Rajasthan Ruminations (Feb 2004)
    Technology and the Indian Elections (Feb 2004)
    2003-04 (Dec 2003)
    Random Musings (Sep 2003)
    Useful Concepts (July 2003)
    Dear Non-Resident Indian (July 2003)
    Tech's 10X Tsunamis (July 2002)
    An Indian in China (Mar 2002)
    Disruptive Technologies (Aug 2001)
    Innovation (Aug 2001)
    Good Books

    - My Business Standard columns
    - More columns at Tech Samachar

    Presentations
    - TiE Bangalore (Dec 2004)
    - BangaloreIT.com (Nov 2004)
    - CIT 2004 (Jan 2004)
    - BangaloreIT.com (Nov 2003)
    - Pune CSI Open-Source Workshop (Sep 2003)
    - Sydney ICT Workshop (Jul 2003)
    - Netcore (Mar 2003)
    - Emergent Democracy (MP Govt, Feb 2003)
    - Vision for Digitally Bridged India (Dec 2002)
    - India Post (Nov 2002)
    - Open-Source for eGovernance (Oct 2002)
    Recent Entries
    Archives
    BlogStreet
    Syndicate
    Powered by
    Movable Type 2.21


    Main - Feedback
    © Rajesh Jain