Monday, September 9, 2002
TC-TS Marketing

Building on my earlier post, we've had some discussions internally on which market segments to target with the Thin Client-Thick Server (TC-TS) solution, and how best to do it. [Also see the TC-TS Economics post, so as to get an idea of the solution pricing.]

I have categorised this discussion into two parts: Generics, wherein I discuss the broad usage categories, and Specifics, wherein I address the first few organisation types that we need to address. Finally, there are some ideas on how we need to proceed.

Generics

  • Terminal Market: Wherever people are using "dumb" terminals, we can now move them to "intelligent" terminals, capable of doing much more since they have a GUI. Another way to think of it is to look at these areas where server-based computing is being used. This could mean replacing Unix terminals, Windows terminals or even Novell Netware terminals. Retail stores could put a terminal at different locations in the store. Banks could install it for automated banking or deploy it at the front-office. Call centres could use it as the desktop for their staff.

  • Shared Access Market: This involves targeting these segments where a computer needs to be used by different people at different points of time. Another way to look at it is to consider the solution to fulfill the computing needs for a floating population. Think of hotel rooms, airline lounges, cybercafes, schools and colleges. The same computer is shared by many. Since data is stored on the server (should the need arise), there is privacy for each user, unlike on a Thick Client hard disk.

  • New "X" Market: The X here means Users, Offices, Residential buildings, etc. Look for new buyers, companies setting up new branches/offices or hiring new people. These are users for whom the total cost of ownership can be lower by upto 67% over 3-years, so there is a clear economic driver. Also, new users may not have the baggage of "unlearning" Windows.

  • Low Usage / Few Apps Market: For those users who just need to have a basic set of applications (email, browsing, letter writing), the TC-TS solution can be more than good enough. Or, it could even be targeted at situations where there is the need only for text-based access. In these situations, cost becomes an important consideration.

    Specifics

  • Hotels: Hotel rooms equipped with a computer connected to the Internet, such that when one walks in, it is possible to be browsing in no more than 2 minutes. There is no need to boot-up one's own computer (if one has it) if the need is for checking web-based mail and browsing. Would I pay USD 10 (Rs 500) per day extra for such a service? Sure! Today, just as a phone and cable connection is assumed in a hotel room, it now becomes possible to give not just an Internet connection but a computer in every room. There is a clear return on investment path for the hotel. Another interesting application can be to create an Intranet with the help of nearby shops to give guests an idea of what's on in the neighbourhood, with the ability to buy and have the items added to the hotel bill. The challenge: networking (doing the cabling).

  • Engineering Colleges: Computer education is mandatory in the first year programme of most engineering colleges. This is where the Thin Client can be used to give exposure to Linux. Students can also set up TCs in their hostel (dorm) rooms.

  • MailServ Customers: We have 100+ corporate customers for our messaging solution. While our initial foray into talking to them was not too positive because of the need for supporting Windows applications, we cannot just ignore the corporate segment. Corporates, after all, account for 75% of computer purchases in India. We need to go to them with support for Windows apps. The approach should be to (a) see if we can use their older machines - this is where they would want to use Citrix today, (b) target non-users, thus helping them downstream computing in their organisation (c) look for users just needing the basic apps so they can be moved to a TC, and (d) solve the Microsoft licences problem with the TC-TS solution. A point to keep in mind: "delight" users, not "disappoint" them. Once we make a few breakthroughs with our MailServ customers, we can then target other corporates. For better chances of success, we need to see the intersection of the "generic" markets with the corporate customers that we target.

    How

    I've been thinking of a multi-pronged approach going ahead:

  • Get the Windows applications working on Linux so we can talk to our corporate MailServ customers with confidence
  • Talk to Hotels and Engineering Colleges in Bombay to begin with
  • Create a Mailer identifying the benefits of the TC-TS solution, and send this out to a database of about 1,000 organisations, inviting them to our weekly seminars (see below)
  • Talk to intermediaries (assemblers, SIs) - they are prospective channel partners
  • Set-up weekly seminars (every Saturday morning in our office) so we can showcase the solution and talk about it in detail to interested organisations
  • Send the TC-TS CDs to a few organisations outside India, so we do not just get limited by geography, and begin work on "internationalising" it also

    In short, we need to think creatively. At the heart of our solution is the concept of a "computer on every desktop". Think of those situations where a computer (rightly priced) could add value. So far, people in emerging markets like India have been used to thinking of computers as luxuries. We want to make it a necessity, a utility. This means thinking bottom-up of all the new markets in which computing can make a difference. One point to keep in mind is that we need 10+ users as a start to make this work in a single location.

    Related Entries:  [All]

  • TC-TS Economics

    I've put together some thoughts on the Thin Client-Thick Server solution from a pricing and total cost of ownership point of view, as a precursor to identifying the early markets (will be posting thoughts on this shortly).

    First, a quick recap on the Strengths and Weaknesses of our TC-TS Solution.

    Strengths

    - reduces cost of hardware needed on desktop / can use old PCs
    - reduces cost of software by leveraging open source
    - Windows-like GUI reduces learning time
    - provides base set of apps (email, browser, unified IM client, word processor, spreadsheet, presentation, PDF reader)
    - can read/write most MS-Office documents
    - can co-exist in a Windows world; this is not an either-or solution (either Windows or Linux TCs)
    - centralised administration can provide IT staff easier and greater control on desktops
    - can control the client desktop entirely from the server
    - centralised storage of data makes backups easier

    Weaknesses

    - need a minimum of 10 users (ideally, 25) to amortise cost of Thick Server
    - LAN speed of 100 Mbps needed due to high data transfer
    - Limited support for Windows applications
    - Non real-time situations (since the TC can occasionally crash - we are working to fix this)
    - No multimedia support on desktop (this is actually possible - not a technical issue, just one of TC cost)
    - needs an admin with some basic knowledge of Linux - and an open mind (because we are not Windows!)

    Costs

    An old PC working as a TC is available for USD 150 (Rs 7.5K). These would be typically low-end Pentiums of mid-to-late 1990s-vintage. Newer stripped-down PCs based on Via or AMD processors can be available for USD 200 (Rs 10K), with an additional USD 100 (Rs 5K) for a new keyboard-mouse-monitor.

    The TS investment would be about USD 1,200 (Rs 60K) for a dual-CPU PIII 1 Ghz server, with software RAID on 2 80 GB disks and 1 GB RAM. Such a server can support a minimum of 30 TCs.

    Our software should be priced at no more than USD 40 (Rs 2K) per user per annum, or USD 4 (Rs 200) per month. The monthly/annual subscription fee ensures regular updates of the software applications.

    So, if we assume that companies / institutions get their own TCs, we can think of a rental model on the TS and software. Assuming 10% p.a. interest on the server pricing and our need to recover the cost in 2 years, this implies a monthly cost of USD 60 (Rs 3K).

    So, if we consider the 3 options of 10, 20 and 30 users in an enterprise, the TS and software rental costs on a per month basis would be as follows:
    - 10 users: USD 60 + 10*4 = USD 100, or USD 10 (Rs 500) ppm (per person-month)
    - 20 users: USD 60 + 20*4 = USD 140, or USD 7 (Rs 350) ppm
    - 30 users: USD 60 + 30*4 = USD 180, or USD 6 (Rs 300) ppm

    This does not include support or training costs.

    Thus, an organisation can now provide hardware and software (a full computing solution) for a one-time cost of USD 150 (Rs 7.5K) for the TC and an annual cost of no more than USD 120 (Rs 6K).

    As a comparison, a Thick Windows desktop would cost USD 600 (Rs 30K) with an additional USD 500 (Rs 25K) for software [Windows XP, MS Office and Anti-Virus].

    3-year TCO

    Taken over a 3-year period, the Total Cost of Ownership, assuming a 10% hardware AMC, is as follows:
    - TC-TS Solutions: USD 150 + 15 + 15 + 3*120 = USD 540 (Rs 27K)
    - Thick Windows Desktop: USD 600 + 60 + 60 + 500 = USD 1220 (Rs 60K)

    The TC-TS option could be even lower if one assumes 30 users (the above assumes 10 users). For 30 users, the 3-year TCO is USD 150+15+15+(3*72) = USD 396 (Rs 20K).

    Thus, the TC-TS solution can bring down total cost of ownership over a 3-year period by 55-67%.

    Thin Client-Thick Server | PermaLink | Comments (1)

    Check out this page for a $200 linux PC from walmart, with multimedia and the works. Only one caveat. No Monitor.

    Posted by Rahul
    TC-TS R&D

    Some of the areas that need more work on the technology side are:

  • Optimising Memory Management, so that when the apps like OpenOffice and Evolution run on different Thin Clients, how can we ensure that there is only one instance on the Thick Server. Currently, each apps is loaded into memory every time it is executed on the TC.

  • Reducing LAN Bandwidth needed from 100 Mbps first to 10 Mbps (so it can run on WiFi) and then to 1 Mbps (for cable modems). There is a lot of data transfer happening between TCs and the TS. In a corporate on a 100 Mbps LAN, it doesn't matter. But in the other situations where we want to target homes or look at a wireless LAN, the bandwidth used is going to make a difference.

  • A closer look at VNC (virtual network computer) software and seeing how we can use it better. Today, we use it to get a Windows desktop on the TC.

  • Architecture and Server Sizing, to support 100+ users. Today, we assume there is a single TS which can support 35-40 users. What if there were more users? How can multiple TSs work together? How do we create a scalable architecture on the server side? We may need to use some Linux clustering ideas.

  • Windows applications support on Linux, either through open source solutions like Wine or commercial solutions like CrossoverOffice, Win4Lin, and others. We need to take common applications like Foxpro, Visual Basic, Oracle, MS-Office and Tally (in India), and make sure we get them running on Linux. We cannot go into enterprises without support for Windows applications.

  • WiFi and Power-line modems testing, to meet the challenge of cabling. It may not always be possible to lay out new Ethernet cables for the TCs. In this situation, we should see (assuming cost were not a constraint) how we can use some of the newer technology to connect the TCs with the TS.

  • Using Mozilla as a platform to build applications, with one idea being to integrate a micro web server into the browser to provide real-time two-way updates. Much of this would be useful as we build out our digital dashboard.

  • Support for other languages, so we can take it internationally. Here, we need to especially see how to support Unicode / double-byte.

    Related Entries:  [All]

  • Userland's Radio and Manila

    John Robb provides an overview of the two software products: "With Manila and Radio it is possible to build a large full featured Intranet on a single server that meets the needs of hundreds of individuals. The two can also be used in concert to quickly build a K-Log network."

    Related Entries:  [All]
    Emergic

    Real-Time Enterprise: Bajarin

    From eWeek:


    Where real-time operations were once the province of nuclear power plants and mission-critical manufacturing processes, the real-time concept has been sneaking into the vocabulary of the "next big thing" technology futurists. The most recent explanation I've heard was during a presentation by Creative Strategies President Tim Bajarin at a CRM expo in New York last week.

    In Bajarin's view, a combination of standards-based integrated applications and wireless devices will let corporate "corridor warriors" always know the financial health of their companies, suppliers and customers.

    Related Entries:  [All]

    TECH TALK: Rethinking the Desktop: Game Over?

    Amongst all the technology innovation of the past decade, the one area that has been relatively untouched is the screen which we see everyday when we start our computers – the desktop. The collection of files, directories, folders and icons has changed little in the past decade. Yes, we have gone through multiple versions of Windows (from 3.1 to 95 to 98 to 2000 to XP). But the basic underlying concepts have remained the same. Desktop innovation has been noticeable by its absence.

    I can think of two reasons for this. Firstly, much of the focus for innovation has been on the Web, though the Web browser seems to be also now frozen in time. The only interesting idea that I have across has been Mozilla’s tabbed browsing, which allows one to open up new windows as tabs making clicking across windows a wee bit easier. Secondly, Microsoft has won the desktop game, and so there seems to be little interest by other companies to see what can be done. Distributing a new product will probably be well nigh impossible since the Windows desktop operating system comes pre-installed on most computers.

    If we look at the two desktop OS alternatives, Apple has of late been trying to come up with innovative ideas for its Mac platform with its OS X, while Linux has had two desktops in the form of KDE and Gnome. While OS X has genuinely tried to make things easier for users, its limited platform availability makes it a non-started. The Linux desktops have simply tried to copy the look-and-feel of Microsoft’s Windows. The underlying feeling behind all this is that the desktop game is over.

    The desktop game is over only as far as the current set of computer users go. For today’s 500 million users, the Microsoft Windows-powered desktop has become more of a gateway to connect to the Internet. The email client (Outlook or Outlook Express) and web browser (Internet Explorer) have effectively become the applications there they spend much of their time, complemented by MS-Office in the workplace and Instant Messaging in homes. And as history has shown, it is very difficult to change entrenched habits.

    But the desktop game is not yet begun if we consider the next 500 million users. This is an audience that has only limited access to computers, if at all. They are in the emerging markets of the world, waiting for a dramatic reduction in the price of computing to adopt the technology. They have no love for one OS over the other; they have no baggage of the past.

    So, can we take many of the discrete innovations that have been happening and apply them to give a different and better experience for these new users? They will be, as a group, less savvy than the current set of users. They will also be children of the Internet – making little distinction between the LAN and the WAN. Their first taste of computing will come in a connected world.

    Tomorrow: The Decade That Was

    Tech Talk | PermaLink | Comments (1)

    The meaning of life is that it stops.

    Posted by BonnerJackson Aaron
    Still-hot Tech Sectors

    Forrester highlights tech hotspots (via TheDeal.com) - security patching, search and UWB:


    Forrester predicts that startups specializing in security patching, that is, filling security holes in corporate enterprise systems, have a bright future. In one memo, Rutstein notes that exploitation of a known security hole causes nearly all security incidents. Yet large enterprises are consistently vulnerable owing to the complexity of finding, assessing and testing those patches.

    In another memo, Forrester software analyst Joshua Walker points to a surge of corporate interest in search technology. Buyers include multinationals that can't find critical intellectual property on their intranets and online sellers with buried merchandise. Walker contends that a single type of search engine meets all large enterprise needs so that there's room for several winners. He also notes that the rewards can be large, citing two startups in the sector, Verity Inc. and Endeca Technologies Inc., which have average-size annual contracts of $385,000 and $450,000, respectively.

    Forrester also projects opportunities for VC investment in a wireless subsector: ultra wideband, also known as UWB or digital pulse wireless. That is a technology for transmitting large amounts of digital data over a wide spectrum of low-power radio frequency bands for a short distance. It can carry signals through doors and other obstacles that tend to reflect signals at more limited bandwidths and at higher power. Rutstein notes that while the military has used UWB for many years, new innovations are bringing it into the commercial sector.

    Related Entries:  [All]
    Emergic

    Site Error

    An error was encountered while publishing this resource.

    Debugging Notice

    Zope has encountered a problem publishing your object.

    Cannot locate object at: http://emergic.com/mtbin


    Troubleshooting Suggestions

    • The URL may be incorrect.
    • The parameters passed to this resource may be incorrect.
    • A resource that this resource relies on may be encountering an error.

    For more detailed information about the error, please refer to error log.

    If the error persists please contact the site maintainer. Thank you for your patience.


    Me
    Entrepreneur, Mumbai, India, Emergic, Netcore, Internet, IndiaWorld, Sify, IIT-Bombay, ColumbiaUniv ... More [Write to Me]

    - MyToday
    - Emergic Ecosystem
    - Netcore
    - Emergic MailServ: Enterprise Messaging
    - Emergic CleanMail: Anti-Virus, Anti-Spam
    - BlogStreet: Blog Profiles, RSS Ecosystem
    - Novatium: Network Computers
    - SEraja: The EventWeb
    - Rajshri Media: Broadband Portal
    - Newsweek on Novatium (Feb 2007)
    - Knowledge@Wharton Interview (Oct 2006)
    - TIME Asia (Mar 2000)

    Free SMS Updates
    Indian mobile users can sms START EMERGIC to 9845398453 to get free daily updates on new additions. [To unsubscribe, sms STOP EMERGIC to 9845398453.]
    My Writings
    Affordable Computing and ICT for Development
    India's Digital Infrastructure (May 2007)
    Envisioning Tomorrow's World (Mar 2007)
    Computing for the Next Billion (Jun 2006)
    City Wi-Fi Networks (Apr 2006)
    Microsoft Live (Nov 2005)
    Internet Tea Leaves (Sep 2005)
    Next-Generation Networks (Jul 2005)
    Disruptions (Jul 2005)
    The Mobile Phone Platform (Feb 2005)
    Microsoft, Bandwidth and Centralised Computing (Jan 2005)
    Computing for Broadband 101 (Jan 2005)
    Tomorrow's World (Nov 2004)
    CommPuting Grid (Nov 2004)
    Massputers, Redux (Oct 2004)
    The Network Computer (Oct 2004)
    Reinventing Computing (Aug 2004)
    Tech Trends (Jul 2004)
    Letter to Arun Shourie (Apr 2004)
    As India Develops (Mar 2004)
    My Mental Model (Dec 2003)
    The Next Billion (Sep 2003)
    Transforming Rural India 2 (Jul 2003)
    The Discovery of India (Jun 2003)
    Transforming Rural India (Mar 2003)
    The Rs 5,000 PC Ecosystem (Jan 2003)
    Disruptive Bridges (Nov 2002)
    India Post: Ideas for Tomorrow (Nov 2002)
    Technology's Next Markets (Oct 2002)
    Server-based Computing (Jul 2002)
    India's Next Decade (Apr 2002)
    The Digital Divide (Apr 2002)
    The Real Wireless Revolution (Mar 2002)
    Envisioning a New India (Jan 2002)
    Emerging Technologies, Emerging Markets (Jan 2002)
    The Indianised Linux Desktop (Nov 2001)
    Mass Market Internet (Nov 2000)

    Enterprise Software and SMEs
    The Coming Age of ASPs (May 2005)
    SMEs and Technology (Oct 2003)
    The Death and Rebirth of Email (Aug 2003)
    IT's Future (Aug 2003)
    Rethinking the Desktop (Sep 2002)
    Rethinking Enterprise Software (Jun 2002)
    Emerging Enterprises and Emergent Networks (Mar 2002)
    Web Services (Nov 2001)
    Alt.Software (Oct 2001)
    The Intelligent, Real-Time Enterprise (June 2001)
    Enterprise Software (Mar 2001)
    SME Tech Utility (Feb 2001)
    Software and SMEs (Jan 2001)
    The Intelligent Enterprise: Integrating CRM, SCM and EIP (Jan 2001)

    Information Management
    The Emerging Internet (May 2007)
    The Now-New-Near Web (Sep 2006)
    Mobile Internet (Aug 2006)
    Video on the Internet (Jun 2006)
    India Internet and Mobile (Feb 2006)
    Rethinking Newspapers (Jan 2006)
    Web 2.0 (Oct 2005)
    The Future of Search (Mar 2005)
    Web 2.0 Conference (Oct 2004)
    Thinking A New Food Portal (Sep 2004)
    Rethinking Search (Jan 2004)
    India.com 2.0 (Jan 2004)
    The Publish-Subscribe Web (Jun 2003)
    Constructing the Memex (May 2003)
    RSS, Blogs and Beyond (Feb 2003)
    Blogging (Feb 2002)
    Harnessing Information (Oct 2001)
    News Refinery (May 2001)

    Entrepreneurship
    When Bad Things Happen (Jan 2007)
    Ventures and Capital (Dec 2006)
    15 Years as an Entrepreneur (Nov 2006)
    Of Blue Oceans and Black Swans (May 2006)
    Let's Build a Business (Apr 2006)
    The Value of Vision (Mar 2006)
    Vision and Worries (Oct 2005)
    Bootstrapping a Business (Oct 2005)
    India Needs More Entrepreneurs (Aug 2005)
    Dotcom Nostalgia (Jun 2005)
    When Things Go Wrong (Apr 2005)
    My Life as an Entrepreneur (Nov 2004)
    An Entrepreneur's Growth Challenge (Sep 2004)
    Creating Options (Sep 2004)
    From Employee to Entrepreneur (Aug 2004)
    A Tale of Two Summers (Aug 2004)
    Crucible Experiences (May 2004)
    The Company (May 2004)
    An Entrepreneur's Attributes (Nov 2003)
    An Entrepreneur's Early Days (Sep 2003)
    Reflections on Ideas and Entrepreneurship (Jul 2003)
    Entrepreneur's Enigmas (Jan 2003)
    The Entrepreneur's Delights (Sep 2002)
    Life as an Entrepreneur (Oct 2001)
    Leadership Lessons from Lagaan (Aug 2001)
    Entrepreneurial Learnings (July 2001)
    Entrepreneurship (Mar 2001)
    The IndiaWorld Story (1997-8)

    Abhishek (my son)
    Photos
    Letter to a Two-Year-Old (Apr 2007)
    Father to Son (Apr 2006)
    Letter to a 2005 Baby (Jun 2005)
    The Making of Abhishek (Jul 2005)

    Moreover
    Facebook (May 2007)
    Doing Education Right (May 2007)
    Reflections from a Dubai Trip (Apr 2007)
    Creating India's New Cities (Apr 2007)
    India's Challenges (Mar 2007)
    3GSM 2007 (Feb 2007)
    Demo 2007 (Feb 2007)
    A Tale of Two Covers (Feb 2007)
    3GSM Mumbai (Feb 2007)
    2007 Tech Trends (Jan 2007)
    The Best of 2006 (Dec 2006)
    Best of Tech Talk 2006 (Dec 2006)
    Cyworld (Nov 2006)
    Two 2.0 Events (Nov 2006)
    Two-Sided Markets (Nov 2006)
    The Rise of YouTube (Oct 2006)
    Gandhigiri (Oct 2006)
    Education and Reservation (May 2006)
    Four Blog Years (May 2006)
    Fooled by Randomness (May 2006)
    Blue Ocean Strategy (May 2006)
    Revolution on the Roads (Apr 2006)
    The MySpace Story (Mar 2006)
    A Presentation at PC Forum (Mar 2006)
    Extreme Competition (Mar 2006)
    3GSM World Congress 2006 (Feb 2006)
    DEMO 2006 (Feb 2006)
    India Rising (Jan 2006)
    2006 Tech Trends (Jan 2006)
    The Best of Tech Talk 2005 (Dec 2005)
    The Best of 2005 (Dec 2005)
    Trains, Planes and Mobiles (Dec 2005)
    Peter Drucker: Management's Newton (Nov 2005)
    India Empowered (Oct 2005)
    Rajasthan Ruminations 2 (Sep 2005)
    Building a Better India (Sep 2005)
    South Korea's IT839 (Jul 2005)
    Shift-Ctrl (Jul 2005)
    Best of Future Tech (Feb 2005)
    Multi-Model Minds (Feb 2005)
    The Best of 2004 (Jan 2005)
    On Watching Swades (Jan 2005)
    The Best of Tech Talk 2004 (Dec 2004)
    India Trends (Dec 2004)
    An American Journey (Aug 2004)
    Black Swans (Aug 2004)
    A Train Journey (Jun 2004)
    An Agenda for the Next Government (May 2004)
    Two Blog Years (May 2004)
    Rajasthan Ruminations (Feb 2004)
    Technology and the Indian Elections (Feb 2004)
    2003-04 (Dec 2003)
    Random Musings (Sep 2003)
    Useful Concepts (July 2003)
    Dear Non-Resident Indian (July 2003)
    Tech's 10X Tsunamis (July 2002)
    An Indian in China (Mar 2002)
    Disruptive Technologies (Aug 2001)
    Innovation (Aug 2001)
    Good Books

    - My Business Standard columns
    - More columns at Tech Samachar

    Presentations
    - TiE Bangalore (Dec 2004)
    - BangaloreIT.com (Nov 2004)
    - CIT 2004 (Jan 2004)
    - BangaloreIT.com (Nov 2003)
    - Pune CSI Open-Source Workshop (Sep 2003)
    - Sydney ICT Workshop (Jul 2003)
    - Netcore (Mar 2003)
    - Emergent Democracy (MP Govt, Feb 2003)
    - Vision for Digitally Bridged India (Dec 2002)
    - India Post (Nov 2002)
    - Open-Source for eGovernance (Oct 2002)
    Recent Entries
    Archives
    BlogStreet
    Syndicate
    Powered by
    Movable Type 2.21


    Main - Feedback
    © Rajesh Jain